Interventions

The Interventions Sub-Committee of the Canadian Defence Lawyers Public Policy Secretariat (PPS) is responsible for receiving and ensuring that all requests for CDL to make interventions are reviewed.

Through the PPS, the Interventions Subcommittee will make recommendations to the Board of Directors about active cases that meet the CDL criteria for Intervention; including that CDL has a unique information or perspective on the matter at hand.

The Interventions Sub-Committee of the Public Policy Secretariat is currently chaired by: Karim N, Hirani, Partner, Zuber & Company Litigation Counsel.

Recommendations for cases in which CDL should intervene can be addressed to the Interventions Sub-Committee c/o danielle@cdlawyers.org.

Recent CDL Interventions:

Court of Appeal Decision, Borok v. Primmum Insurance Company, 2026 ONCA 748

CDL participated as one of three intervenors in this appeal before the Court of Appeal. In its decision released on September 25, 2026, the Court allowed the appeal, providing important guidance and greater certainty regarding the settlement of Accident Benefits claims involving parties under disability. 

CDL was represented by Philippa Samworth and Andrea Lim of Dutton Brock LLP. We thank them for their hard work and advocacy throughout this appeal and for helping secure this positive result for CDL members and those they serve.

Court of Appeal decision, Kolapully v. Myles, 2024 ONCA 350

While the appeal involved four issues, CDL sought intervenor status on only one: the deductibility of on-earner benefits from a tort award under section 267.8 of the Insurance Act. The Court of Appeal allowed this part of the appeal, finding that non-earner benefits are in the silo of income replacement benefits and are therefore deductible. Given that other Provinces throughout Canada have no-fault benefit regimes, this decision acts as persuasive authority in those jurisdictions and the CDL is happy to have made such a national contribution to the development of the law in this regard. 

In achieving this successful outcome, CDL would like to extend its gratitude to David A. Zuber and James Tausendfreund of Zuber & Company, LLP, Litigation Counsel who acted for the CDL on this appeal.
 
 

CDL Intervenor Policy – Last Updated June 2023

  1. Intervention may be considered at the request of a member or by the Board of its own motion.
  2. In either case it should be considered as far in advance of the date for intervening or seeking leave to intervene as practical and only by exception less than 60 days before materials must be filed.
  3. CDL will intervene only where the intervention would constitute a significant contribution to the consideration of the issue(s) involved, and only when the position sought to be advanced is a matter of compelling interest or special significance to the civil defence bar or the client industry. If the issue(s) to be addressed are not of national significance, CDL may intervene in matters of local or regional concern provided that the national focus of CDL is taken into account when deciding whether to intervene, and provided that the position sought to be advanced in the intervention otherwise meets the requirements of this policy.
  4. Intervention at first instance should arise infrequently.
  5. In considering whether to intervene, the following shall be considered:
  1. available material/information about the intervention,
  2. whether it has been demonstrated that the matter is of compelling interest or special significance to the civil defence bar or the client industry at the national, local or regional level,
  3. whether the importance of and need for CDL’s involvement is demonstrated, and
  4. whether there are any reasons CDL should not intervene, including the expenditure of time or resources, reputational risk, or otherwise.
  1. Following consideration by the Intervenor Group, requests to intervene will be shared with the Public Policy Secretariat Steering Committee, and placed on the agenda of the next Board of Directors meeting. Where time constraints require consideration before the next Board meeting, the Chair of the Intervenor Group may request a decision by the Executive Committee.
  2. When providing the Board or Executive Committee with materials, the Intervenor Group will provide its recommendation as to whether CDL ought to intervene. The Board or Executive Committee will consider, but is not bound by, the recommendation.
  3. CDL may maintain a voluntary list of members willing to act essentially pro bono in all provinces, but the Board retains full unfettered discretion to select counsel of its choice, whether they are on the list of volunteers or not.
  4. Any written submissions must be reviewed by the committee or its nominee before it is filed and with sufficient time to allow for meaningful comment and amendment. Nothing that the committeeor its nominee does not approve may be filed or argued by counsel.
  5. Cost must be strictly controlled. CDL should have a cap, in a very low amount, as to the maximum it will disburse with respect to any intervention. An amount for first purposes should be $3,000. The purpose of the funding is not to pay counsel for time but to assist in offsetting disbursements.
  6. CDL may, rather than intervene directly, decide to lend official support (including financial support) within the guidelines set out in this policy to other intervenors.